Written by Amy Cunningham on December 21, 2012
Since nine medical specialty societies announced their lists of “Five Things Physicians and Patients Should Question” in April, 55 published journal articles have referenced the Choosing Wisely® campaign. For the final Recommended Reading post of 2012, we’ve culled a selection of those articles, and will share more in the new year.
In order of publication date:
- ABIM and ABIM Foundation President and CEO Christine K. Cassel, MD, and President and CEO of Consumer Reports, James Guest, JD, helped to kick off the campaign with theJAMA commentary, Choosing Wisely: Helping Physicians and Patients Make Smart Choices about their Care.
- In From an Ethics of Rationing to an Ethics of Waste Avoidance, Howard Brody argued for a stepwise strategy to eliminate unnecessary care given the limitations of comparative-effectiveness research, saying, “it is better first to eliminate interventions for which we have the most solid and indisputable evidence of a lack of benefit.”
- In Application of “Less Is More” to Low Back Pain, the authors found strong evidence supporting the American Academy of Family Physicians’ recommendation as part of theChoosing Wisely campaign, “Don’t do imaging for low back pain within the first 6 weeks unless red flags are present.” The article was accompanied by a commentary by ABIM Foundation Executive Vice President and Chief Operating Officer Daniel Wolfson.
- In the New England Journal of Medicine article, A Systemic Approach to Containing Health Care Spending, Ezekiel Emanuel, MD, PhD and co-authors outlined a number of recommendations for bending the health care cost curve, including the development of credible practice guidelines.
- A British Medical Journal piece on unnecessary care said that a “newly launched movement lead by prominent doctors is challenging the basic assumption in U.S. healthcare that more is better” and cited Choosing Wisely as part of the movement
- Authors of a JAMA commentary mentioned the Choosing Wisely campaign as one of several recent initiatives addressing the physician’s role in health care expenditures. They then call for a new model of medical education that celebrates restraint in ordering health care tests and procedures.
- An Annals of Internal Medicine piece discussed the potential impact of Choosing Wisely recommendations for radiology and argues, “Current campaigns that draw attention to overuse of imaging studies coupled with greater physician knowledge and use of the criteria for appropriate imaging can help to ensure a further reduction in unnecessary testing—a result that would benefit both patients and our health care system.”
- In Choosing Wisely: Low-Value Services, Utilization, and Patient Cost Sharing, researchers from the University of Pennsylvania reflected on the Choosing Wisely campaign and asked, “But if it is difficult in many situations for patients to choose wisely, and if there are significant challenges in getting physicians to choose wisely, then who should be doing the choosing?”
- The Texas Medical Association explored the Choosing Wisely campaign and what it means to their members in Choosing Wisely: More Value, Less Waste, Shared Decision-Making. (Note, the article begins on page 25.)
We look forward to continuing the conversations on professionalism and Choosing Wisely in 2013, and wish our readers a happy and healthy new year.